Stirrup Cup Pizza

Delicious pizza and pizza sticks!

My favorite deep dish pizza of all time! Pepperoni and pineapple is my go to order (I know it sounds weird and I was so skeptical when my friend introduced this to me bc I have never liked pineapple on a pizza). If you like traditional pizza this place is a must.

Awesome pizza

This hole in the wall has some of the best pizza in the country. Fresh ingredients, plenty of cheese, and buttery crust. The interior is quaintly western and the staff is friendly.

Great all meat pizza!

Love it.

They make pizza the best way with provolone instead of mozzarella. Same texture with better flavor. I prefer the thin crust. Favorite pizzeria in area.

Most tasty deep dish pizza in an old time Western themed decor.

Favorite pizza now

Yum! We hadn't had a pizza in quite a while so we decided to give it a try. So glad! They have a nice variety of toppings, a choice of thin, pan, or stuffed crust style, and good draft beer. A real treat!

12 years of being a customer not one bad pizza.

Simply the best pizza on the Monterey Peninsula. Others don't come close. Stay home, stay local!!

Nice, casual and old school deep dish or thin crust. Old. West decor, games and live music some nights. Friendly staff makes this a winner.

Delicious

Very good pizza reasonably priced. The waitress should be careful not to chew chewing gum loudely with mouth open while taking the order, it is kind of rude and made me order take away instead of staying in this charming little restaurant

Nice thin crust, clean fresh ingredients.

Best in Carmel Valley

Amazing stuffed pizza (Chicago Style). Quaint ambience, great staff.

Best pizza in Carmel Valley hands down! Honest helpful staff, old school love!

Good pizza at a reasonable price, this place is like walking back into a slice of Carmel Valley history. Closed on Tuesday and some holidays (like Mothers day) they also serve beer and wine.

If you like lots of toppings, cheese and a variety of choices this is your place. A gooey mess of delicious Every time.

The pizza was really nice but the table was not cleaned properly and the restaurant had a smell to it that wasn't really pleasant to consume food in. Too expensive for me.

Great deep dish pies.

Very nice and friendly staff with tasty quality pizzas. Great house ranch dressing. My personal favorite is Chiken Ceasar and I highly recommend it.

Garlic chicken pizza